Excellent ceramic, not flat though
I bought all three Spyderco bench stones (medium, fine, ultra fine) from Heinnie. Great service, can't knock it. In terms of the stones; the ultra fine was very well finished and pretty much perfectly flat, the fine had rough edges and lipped slightly at the edges, and the medium was pretty dreadful - huge ridges at the sides which erase any bevel as soon as you've created it. Looking around online I think this is quite common. I bought a cheap diamond abrasive block (60 grit) and lapping stone (180) grit from amazon, ground down the edges and lapped the first two flat. Now, they're by far the best stones I've ever used - they cut well and barely load up at all if used wet, mirror edges with ease. In summary, definitely buy them, but be sure to lap them before you get going; it really pays dividends.